Philadelphia Phillies and Pittsburgh Pirates players: who played for both

Who played for both the Phillies and Pirates?

281 players played for both the Philadelphia Phillies and the Pittsburgh Pirates between 1883 and 2025, including Andrew McCutchen, Lloyd Waner, Chuck Klein and Gus Suhr. 120 of them played for the Phillies first and 149 for the Pirates first; 12 played for both in the same season.

Did you know?

Jack Neagle is the earliest on this list to complete the pair: Phillies first, then the Pirates from 1883.
Tim Mayza is the most recent: Phillies first, then the Pirates from 2025.
Andrew McCutchen played the most games across the two: 260 for the Phillies and 1,713 for the Pirates.
63 of them had two or more separate spells with one of the teams, such as Andrew McCutchen.
Most common positions on this list: P (123), OF (64), C (25), 2B (22).

How many can you name?

Name players who played for both the Phillies and the Pirates. The surname is enough. 0 / 281

All 281 players, most games for the two first

Seasons and regular-season games with each franchise (1876–2025). A gap of a season or more starts a new spell.
Player	Pos	Phillies	Pirates
Andrew McCutchen	OF	2019–2021 (260 g)	2009–2017, 2023–2025 (1713 g)
Lloyd Waner	OF	1942 (101 g)	1927–1941, 1944–1945 (1803 g)
Chuck Klein	OF	1928–1933, 1936–1944 (1405 g)	1939 (85 g)
Gus Suhr	1B	1939–1940 (70 g)	1930–1939 (1365 g)
Dick Groat	SS	1966–1967 (165 g)	1952, 1955–1962 (1258 g)
Richie Hebner	3B	1977–1978 (255 g)	1968–1976, 1982–1983 (1140 g)
Roy Thomas	OF	1899–1908, 1910–1911 (1287 g)	1908 (101 g)
Al Oliver	OF	1984 (28 g)	1968–1977 (1302 g)
Kitty Bransfield	1B	1905–1911 (814 g)	1901–1904 (507 g)
Bill Robinson	OF	1972–1974, 1982–1983 (351 g)	1975–1982 (805 g)
Andy Van Slyke	OF	1995 (63 g)	1987–1994 (1057 g)
Virgil Davis	C	1928–1933, 1938–1939 (814 g)	1940–1941, 1944–1945 (233 g)
Kent Tekulve	P	1985–1988 (291 g)	1974–1985 (722 g)
Frank Thomas	OF	1964–1965 (74 g)	1951–1958 (925 g)
Otto Knabe	2B	1907–1913 (949 g)	1905, 1916 (31 g)
Lee Handley	3B	1947 (101 g)	1937–1941, 1944–1946 (843 g)
Dick Bartell	SS	1931–1934 (587 g)	1927–1930 (345 g)
Smoky Burgess	C	1952–1955 (327 g)	1959–1964 (586 g)
Dave Cash	2B	1974–1976 (484 g)	1969–1973 (420 g)
Bobby Byrne	3B	1913–1917 (311 g)	1909–1913 (590 g)
Dots Miller	1B	1920–1921 (182 g)	1909–1913 (711 g)
Abraham Nunez	3B	2006–2007 (259 g)	1997–2004 (630 g)
Josh Harrison	2B	2023 (41 g)	2011–2018 (842 g)
Neil Walker	2B	2020 (18 g)	2009–2015 (836 g)
Vince DiMaggio	OF	1945–1946 (133 g)	1940–1944 (670 g)
George Whitted	OF	1915–1919 (524 g)	1919–1921 (277 g)
Danny Murtaugh	2B	1941–1943, 1946 (348 g)	1948–1951 (416 g)
Glenn Wilson	OF	1984–1987 (602 g)	1988–1989, 1993 (147 g)
Tommy Thevenow	SS	1929–1930 (246 g)	1931–1935, 1938 (499 g)
Willie Montanez	1B	1970–1975, 1982 (651 g)	1981–1982 (65 g)
Dick Stuart	1B	1965 (149 g)	1958–1962 (559 g)
Don Hoak	3B	1963–1964 (121 g)	1959–1962 (576 g)
Monte Cross	SS	1898–1901 (573 g)	1894–1895 (122 g)
Jose Pagan	SS	1973 (46 g)	1965–1972 (625 g)
Johnny Wyrostek	OF	1946–1947, 1952–1954 (588 g)	1942–1943 (60 g)
Charlie Hayes	3B	1989–1991, 1995 (519 g)	1996 (128 g)
Al Todd	C	1932–1935 (304 g)	1936–1938 (342 g)
Mike LaValliere	C	1984 (6 g)	1987–1993 (609 g)
Jim Morrison	3B	1977–1978 (58 g)	1982–1987 (552 g)
Gene Freese	3B	1959 (132 g)	1955–1958, 1964–1965 (472 g)
Earl Grace	C	1936–1937 (166 g)	1931–1935 (427 g)
Fresco Thompson	2B	1927–1930 (575 g)	1925 (14 g)
Wally Westlake	OF	1956 (5 g)	1947–1951 (580 g)
Johnny Mokan	OF	1922–1927 (532 g)	1921–1922 (50 g)
Mike Easler	OF	1987 (33 g)	1977, 1979–1983 (549 g)
Jimmy Wasdell	OF	1943–1946 (434 g)	1942–1943 (126 g)
Duff Cooley	OF	1896–1899 (440 g)	1900 (66 g)
Hans Lobert	3B	1911–1914 (497 g)	1903 (5 g)
Fred Brickell	OF	1930–1933 (236 g)	1926–1930 (265 g)
Gary Redus	OF	1986 (90 g)	1988–1992 (398 g)
Jason Michaels	OF	2001–2005 (383 g)	2008 (102 g)
Sean Rodriguez	2B	2019 (76 g)	2015–2018 (384 g)
Grant Jackson	P	1965–1970 (180 g)	1977–1982 (278 g)
Johnny Rizzo	OF	1940–1941 (202 g)	1938–1940 (246 g)
Marlon Byrd	OF	2002–2005, 2014 (410 g)	2013 (30 g)
Babe Dahlgren	1B	1943 (136 g)	1944–1945 (302 g)
Mike Williams	P	1992–1996, 2003 (128 g)	1998–2003 (306 g)
Jose Bautista	OF	2018 (27 g)	2004–2008 (400 g)
Cliff Lee	OF	1921–1924 (338 g)	1919–1920 (79 g)
Mike Ryan	C	1968–1973 (392 g)	1974 (15 g)
Cotton Tierney	2B	1923 (121 g)	1920–1923 (280 g)
Charlie Reilly	3B	1892–1895 (284 g)	1891 (114 g)
Tom Padden	C	1943 (17 g)	1932–1937 (379 g)
Doug Baird	3B	1919 (66 g)	1915–1917 (316 g)
Antonio Bastardo	P	2009–2014 (275 g)	2015–2017 (103 g)
John Coleman	OF	1883–1884 (133 g)	1886–1888, 1890 (245 g)
Johnny Rawlings	2B	1920–1921 (158 g)	1923–1926 (219 g)
Pop Schriver	C	1888–1890 (152 g)	1898–1900 (224 g)
Jose Mesa	P	2001–2003, 2007 (246 g)	2004–2005 (125 g)
Don Robinson	P	1992 (10 g)	1978–1987 (355 g)
Ed Abbaticchio	2B	1897–1898 (28 g)	1907–1910 (334 g)
Beals Becker	OF	1913–1915 (338 g)	1908 (20 g)
Mike Benjamin	SS	1996 (35 g)	1999–2000, 2002 (311 g)
Gary Varsho	OF	1995 (72 g)	1991–1992, 1994 (269 g)
Lee Walls	OF	1960–1961 (156 g)	1952, 1956–1957 (183 g)
Denny Sothern	OF	1926, 1928–1930 (321 g)	1930 (17 g)
Jared Hughes	P	2019 (25 g)	2011–2016 (313 g)
Ken Heintzelman	P	1947–1952 (165 g)	1937–1942, 1946–1947 (156 g)
Andrew Knapp	C	2017–2021 (309 g)	2022 (11 g)
Ronny Cedeno	SS	2014 (7 g)	2009–2011 (313 g)
Billy Sunday	OF	1890 (31 g)	1888–1890 (287 g)
Murry Dickson	P	1954–1956 (79 g)	1949–1953 (234 g)
Lee Meadows	P	1919–1923 (129 g)	1923–1929 (183 g)
Bob Walk	P	1980 (27 g)	1984–1993 (280 g)
Frank Shugart	SS	1897 (40 g)	1891–1893 (264 g)
Rollie Hemsley	C	1946–1947 (51 g)	1928–1931 (252 g)
Hal Carlson	P	1924–1927 (127 g)	1917–1923 (172 g)
Joe Bowman	P	1935–1936 (93 g)	1937–1941 (202 g)
Lance Parrish	C	1987–1988 (253 g)	1994 (40 g)
Dick Hall	P	1967–1968 (80 g)	1952–1957, 1959 (211 g)
Lonnie Smith	OF	1978–1981 (196 g)	1993 (94 g)
Howie Camnitz	P	1913 (9 g)	1904, 1906–1913 (277 g)
Casey Stengel	OF	1920–1921 (153 g)	1918–1919 (128 g)
Jim Bunning	P	1964–1967, 1970–1971 (229 g)	1968–1969 (52 g)
Gene Garber	P	1974–1978 (250 g)	1969–1970, 1972 (20 g)
Bobby Del Greco	OF	1960–1961, 1965 (149 g)	1952, 1956 (113 g)
Turner Ward	OF	2001 (17 g)	1997–1999 (243 g)
Harvey Haddix	P	1956–1957 (87 g)	1959–1963 (169 g)
Carlos Santana	1B	2018 (161 g)	2023 (94 g)
Tully Sparks	P	1897, 1903–1910 (224 g)	1899 (28 g)
George McQuillan	P	1907–1910, 1915–1916 (149 g)	1913–1915 (100 g)
Bill Duggleby	P	1898, 1901–1907 (232 g)	1907 (9 g)
Dale Sveum	SS	1992 (54 g)	1996–1997, 1999 (187 g)
Ty Wigginton	3B	2012 (125 g)	2004–2005 (115 g)
Wally Backman	2B	1991–1992 (136 g)	1990 (104 g)
Erskine Mayer	P	1912–1918 (206 g)	1918–1919 (33 g)
Lee King	OF	1921–1922 (83 g)	1916–1918 (155 g)
Eddie Pellagrini	SS	1951 (86 g)	1953–1954 (151 g)
Matt Stairs	OF	2008–2009 (115 g)	2003 (121 g)
Max Butcher	P	1938–1939 (32 g)	1939–1945 (204 g)
Midre Cummings	OF	1997 (63 g)	1993–1997 (172 g)
Jeanmar Gomez	P	2015–2017 (153 g)	2013–2014 (78 g)
Charles Zimmer	C	1903 (37 g)	1900–1902 (193 g)
Dan Plesac	P	2002–2003 (99 g)	1995–1996 (131 g)
Tom Foley	SS	1985–1986 (85 g)	1993–1994 (145 g)
Bill Almon	SS	1988 (20 g)	1985–1987 (209 g)
Jon Lieber	P	2005–2007 (78 g)	1994–1998 (151 g)
Tom Prince	C	1999–2000 (50 g)	1987–1993 (177 g)
Ed Konetchy	1B	1921 (72 g)	1914 (154 g)
Hugh Mulcahy	P	1935–1940, 1945–1946 (221 g)	1947 (2 g)
Woodie Fryman	P	1968–1972 (157 g)	1966–1967 (64 g)
Claude Willoughby	P	1925–1930 (210 g)	1931 (9 g)
Larry McWilliams	P	1989 (41 g)	1982–1986 (173 g)
Corey Dickerson	OF	2019 (34 g)	2018–2019 (179 g)
Otto Krueger	SS	1905 (47 g)	1903–1904 (166 g)
Ted Savage	OF	1962 (127 g)	1963 (85 g)
Al Maul	OF	1887, 1900 (21 g)	1888–1889, 1891 (189 g)
Cy Blanton	P	1940–1942 (47 g)	1934–1939 (155 g)
Brandon Moss	OF	2011 (5 g)	2008–2010 (195 g)
Sixto Lezcano	OF	1983–1984 (127 g)	1985 (72 g)
Bill Gray	3B	1890–1891 (57 g)	1898 (137 g)
Jocko Fields	OF	1891 (8 g)	1887–1889, 1891 (186 g)
Kenny Lofton	OF	2005 (110 g)	2003 (84 g)
Rodolfo Castro	2B	2023 (14 g)	2021–2023 (180 g)
Terry Mulholland	P	1989–1993, 1996 (170 g)	2001 (22 g)
Joe Schultz	OF	1924–1925 (112 g)	1916 (77 g)
Michael Martinez	OF	2011–2013 (162 g)	2014 (26 g)
Kirby Higbe	P	1939–1940 (75 g)	1947–1949 (109 g)
Don Cardwell	P	1957–1960 (77 g)	1963–1966 (106 g)
Matt Joyce	OF	2021 (43 g)	2016 (140 g)
Al Holland	P	1983–1985 (139 g)	1977, 1985 (40 g)
Randall Simon	1B	2006 (23 g)	2003–2004 (152 g)
Bobby Tolan	OF	1976–1977 (125 g)	1977 (49 g)
Earl Hamilton	P	1924 (3 g)	1918–1923 (169 g)
Nick Strincevich	P	1948 (6 g)	1941–1942, 1944–1948 (162 g)
Rick White	P	2006 (38 g)	1994–1995, 2005 (129 g)
Juan Nicasio	P	2017, 2019 (49 g)	2016–2017 (117 g)
Jimmy Bloodworth	2B	1950–1951 (75 g)	1947 (88 g)
Brian Hunter	1B	2000 (85 g)	1994 (76 g)
Lou Collier	SS	2004 (32 g)	1997–1998 (128 g)
Erik Kratz	C	2011–2013, 2015 (132 g)	2010, 2016 (27 g)
Claude Passeau	P	1936–1939 (153 g)	1935 (1 g)
Gus Weyhing	P	1892–1895 (151 g)	1895 (1 g)
Rod Barajas	C	2007 (48 g)	2012 (104 g)
Frank Schulte	OF	1917 (65 g)	1916–1917 (85 g)
Charlie Morton	P	2016 (4 g)	2009–2015 (142 g)
Vince Velasquez	P	2016–2021 (138 g)	2023 (8 g)
Barry Jones	P	1992 (44 g)	1986–1988 (100 g)
Earl Browne	OF	1937–1938 (126 g)	1935–1936 (18 g)
Jose Hernandez	SS	2006 (18 g)	2003, 2006 (125 g)
Benito Santiago	C	1996 (136 g)	2005 (6 g)
Boom-Boom Beck	P	1939–1943 (128 g)	1945 (14 g)
Mark Parent	C	1997–1998 (73 g)	1995 (69 g)
Whitey Glazner	P	1923–1924 (63 g)	1920–1923 (79 g)
Jimmy Smith	2B	1921–1922 (105 g)	1916 (36 g)
Lew Moren	P	1907–1910 (139 g)	1903–1904 (2 g)
Al Gerheauser	P	1943–1944 (70 g)	1945–1946 (69 g)
Eddie Burke	OF	1890 (100 g)	1890 (31 g)
Elmer Jacobs	P	1914, 1918–1919 (49 g)	1916–1918 (80 g)
Roger Mason	P	1993–1994 (40 g)	1991–1992 (89 g)
Joe Blanton	P	2008–2012 (105 g)	2015 (21 g)
A. J. Burnett	P	2014 (34 g)	2012–2013, 2015 (87 g)
Johnny Podgajny	P	1940–1943 (96 g)	1943 (21 g)
Bud Hafey	OF	1939 (18 g)	1935–1936 (97 g)
Joe Boever	P	1990–1991 (102 g)	1996 (13 g)
Dick Davis	OF	1981–1982 (73 g)	1982 (39 g)
Jose DeLeon	P	1992–1993 (27 g)	1983–1986 (85 g)
Bob Oldis	C	1962–1963 (85 g)	1960–1961 (26 g)
Philip Gosselin	2B	2019–2020 (83 g)	2017 (28 g)
Bailey Falter	P	2021–2023 (50 g)	2023–2025 (60 g)
Lloyd Dietz	P	1943 (21 g)	1940–1943 (89 g)
Roberto Hernandez	P	2004 (63 g)	2006 (46 g)
Harry Decker	C	1889–1890 (16 g)	1890 (92 g)
Jose Contreras	P	2010–2012 (101 g)	2013 (7 g)
Pedro Florimon	SS	2017–2018 (65 g)	2015–2016 (42 g)
Stuffy McInnis	1B	1927 (1 g)	1925–1926 (106 g)
Ken Brett	P	1973 (37 g)	1974–1975 (69 g)
Frank Ringo	C	1883–1884 (86 g)	1885–1886 (18 g)
Cal Neeman	C	1960–1961 (78 g)	1962 (24 g)
Cozy Dolan	OF	1912–1913 (67 g)	1913 (35 g)
Gus Dugas	OF	1933 (37 g)	1930, 1932 (64 g)
Vance Worley	P	2010–2012 (53 g)	2014–2015 (44 g)
Bob Ferguson	2B	1883 (86 g)	1884 (10 g)
Carmelo Martinez	OF	1990 (71 g)	1990–1991 (23 g)
Dave Rucker	P	1985–1986 (60 g)	1988 (31 g)
Jack Neagle	P	1883 (18 g)	1883–1884 (70 g)
Erv Kantlehner	P	1916 (3 g)	1914–1916 (84 g)
Jack Scott	P	1927 (83 g)	1916 (3 g)
Manny Martinez	OF	1996 (13 g)	1998 (73 g)
Ed Holley	P	1932–1934 (80 g)	1934 (5 g)
Bubber Jonnard	C	1926–1927, 1935 (73 g)	1922 (10 g)
Doug Bair	P	1987 (11 g)	1976, 1989–1990 (70 g)
Jerad Eickhoff	P	2015–2019 (80 g)	2022 (1 g)
Ad Gumbert	P	1896 (11 g)	1893–1894 (68 g)
Sam Gillen	SS	1897 (75 g)	1893 (3 g)
Harry McCormick	OF	1908 (11 g)	1904 (66 g)
Johnny Lindell	OF	1953–1954 (18 g)	1953 (58 g)
Bill White	SS	1883 (1 g)	1884 (74 g)
Chase d'Arnaud	SS	2015 (11 g)	2011–2012, 2014 (64 g)
Danny Jackson	P	1993–1994 (58 g)	1992 (15 g)
Mike Maddux	P	1986–1989 (65 g)	1995 (8 g)
Duke Esper	P	1890–1892 (67 g)	1890, 1892 (5 g)
Patsy Flaherty	P	1910 (2 g)	1900, 1904–1905 (70 g)
Cal McLish	P	1962–1964 (67 g)	1947–1948 (4 g)
Chan Ho Park	P	2009 (45 g)	2010 (26 g)
Billy Hatcher	OF	1994 (43 g)	1989 (27 g)
Clise Dudley	P	1931–1932 (67 g)	1933 (1 g)
Ed Sicking	2B	1919 (61 g)	1927 (7 g)
Yacksel Rios	P	2017–2019 (53 g)	2019–2020 (13 g)
Austin Davis	P	2018–2020 (50 g)	2020–2021 (15 g)
Kevin Elster	SS	1995 (26 g)	1997 (39 g)
Kevin Correia	P	2015 (5 g)	2011–2012 (59 g)
Neftali Feliz	P	2021 (2 g)	2016 (62 g)
Bobby Shantz	P	1964 (14 g)	1961 (44 g)
J. A. Happ	P	2007–2010 (47 g)	2015 (11 g)
John Bowker	1B	2011 (12 g)	2010–2011 (45 g)
Matt Kata	2B	2005 (10 g)	2007 (47 g)
Brad Lincoln	P	2014 (2 g)	2010–2012 (53 g)
Nelson Figueroa	P	2001, 2010 (32 g)	2003–2004 (22 g)
Art Madison	2B	1895 (11 g)	1899 (42 g)
Chad Qualls	P	2012 (35 g)	2012 (17 g)
Chet Nichols	P	1930–1932 (41 g)	1926–1927 (11 g)
Joaquin Benoit	P	2017 (44 g)	2017 (8 g)
Omar Olivares	P	1995 (5 g)	2001 (47 g)
Bo Belinsky	P	1965–1966 (40 g)	1969 (8 g)
Danny Cox	P	1991–1992 (32 g)	1992 (16 g)
George Susce	C	1929 (17 g)	1939 (31 g)
Jason Boyd	P	2000 (30 g)	1999, 2004 (16 g)
Enyel De Los Santos	P	2018–2019, 2021 (38 g)	2021 (7 g)
Mike Zagurski	P	2007, 2010–2011 (37 g)	2013 (6 g)
Chuck Hiller	2B	1967 (31 g)	1968 (11 g)
Hank Borowy	P	1949–1950 (31 g)	1950 (11 g)
Jack Taschner	P	2009 (24 g)	2010 (17 g)
Lou Koupal	P	1929–1930 (28 g)	1925–1926 (13 g)
Morgan Murphy	C	1898, 1900 (36 g)	1898 (5 g)
Freddie Toliver	P	1985–1987 (26 g)	1993 (12 g)
Mark Ryal	OF	1989 (29 g)	1990 (9 g)
John McDonald	SS	2013 (21 g)	2013 (16 g)
Phenomenal Smith	P	1890–1891 (29 g)	1884, 1890 (6 g)
Jayson Nix	3B	2014 (18 g)	2014 (16 g)
Juan Perez	P	2011 (8 g)	2006–2007 (24 g)
Conny Doyle	OF	1883 (16 g)	1884 (15 g)
Heath Hembree	P	2020 (11 g)	2022 (20 g)
Harry Shuman	P	1944 (18 g)	1942–1943 (12 g)
Josh Lindblom	P	2012 (26 g)	2017 (4 g)
Jay Clarke	C	1919 (26 g)	1920 (3 g)
Ray Steineder	P	1924 (9 g)	1923–1924 (20 g)
Ray Harrell	P	1939 (22 g)	1940 (3 g)
Charlie Starr	2B	1909 (3 g)	1908 (21 g)
Bob Kuzava	P	1955 (17 g)	1957 (4 g)
Dave Anderson	P	1889–1890 (8 g)	1890 (13 g)
Sheriff Blake	P	1931 (14 g)	1920 (6 g)
Deolis Guerra	P	2020 (9 g)	2015 (10 g)
Dick Conger	P	1943 (13 g)	1941–1942 (5 g)
Drew Hutchison	P	2018 (11 g)	2016 (6 g)
Kaiser Wilhelm	P	1921 (4 g)	1903 (13 g)
Phil Knell	P	1892 (11 g)	1888, 1894 (4 g)
Tim Mayza	P	2025 (8 g)	2025 (7 g)
Bill Day	P	1889–1890 (8 g)	1890 (6 g)
Piggy Ward	OF	1883, 1889 (8 g)	1891 (6 g)
The Only Nolan	P	1885 (7 g)	1883 (7 g)
Lil Stoner	P	1931 (7 g)	1930 (5 g)
Pedro Ramos	P	1967 (6 g)	1969 (5 g)
Sumner Bowman	P	1890 (1 g)	1890 (10 g)
Dave LaPoint	P	1991 (2 g)	1988 (8 g)
Hardie Henderson	P	1883 (2 g)	1888 (5 g)
Warren McLaughlin	P	1900, 1903 (4 g)	1902 (3 g)
King Brady	P	1905 (2 g)	1906–1907 (4 g)
Ralph Capron	OF	1913 (5 g)	1912 (1 g)
Alex Jones	P	1894 (1 g)	1889 (1 g)
Tom Delahanty	2B	1894 (1 g)	1896 (1 g)

From the SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0), 1876–2025. A season counts when the player played at least one regular-season game for the franchise.Phillies seasons include the Philadelphia Quakers (1883–1889) and Philadelphia Blue Jays (1943–1944).Pirates seasons include the Pittsburg Alleghenys (1882–1890).

What next? Play today's MLB Grid

Fill a 3×3 board of team pairs like this one, with nine guesses and a rarity score. New board every day.

Play the MLB Grid MLB career path Phillies history Pirates history

More “played for both” lists

Philadelphia Phillies and…

Cardinals 323 Cubs 322 Reds 285 Braves 268 Dodgers 265 Giants 263 Guardians 202 Orioles 200 Red Sox 190 White Sox 183

Pittsburgh Pirates and…

Cubs 298 Cardinals 289 Braves 283 Reds 269 Dodgers 262 Giants 252 Yankees 223 Guardians 203 Orioles 182 White Sox 174

All MLB team pairs

Questions

How many players have played for both the Philadelphia Phillies and the Pittsburgh Pirates?

281 in the Lahman Baseball Database from 1883 to 2025, including Andrew McCutchen, Lloyd Waner, Chuck Klein and Gus Suhr. A player counts when he played at least one regular-season game for each franchise.

Who was the first player on this list to play for both?

Jack Neagle: Philadelphia Phillies first, then the Pittsburgh Pirates from 1883.

Who has played for both recently?

Andrew McCutchen, Bailey Falter and Tim Mayza, with a season for one of the two in 2024 or 2025.

Does a player count if the team has moved or changed its name?

Yes. Seasons count for today's franchise, the way the Lahman database links every team-season to a franchise. Phillies seasons include the Philadelphia Quakers (1883–1889) and Philadelphia Blue Jays (1943–1944). Pirates seasons include the Pittsburg Alleghenys (1882–1890).

Careers from the SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0). Team logos are trademarks of their respective teams (logos via TheSportsDB). Independent and not affiliated with MLB or any team. Credits