Philadelphia Phillies and San Francisco Giants players: who played for both

Who played for both the Phillies and Giants?

263 players played for both the Philadelphia Phillies and the San Francisco Giants between 1883 and 2025, including Garry Maddox, Art Fletcher, Pat Burrell and George Burns. 110 of them played for the Phillies first and 144 for the Giants first; 9 played for both in the same season.

Did you know?

Jim Devlin is the earliest on this list to complete the pair: Giants first, then the Phillies from 1887.
Lou Trivino is the most recent: Phillies first, then the Giants from 2025.
Garry Maddox played the most games across the two: 1,328 for the Phillies and 421 for the Giants.
53 of them had two or more separate spells with one of the teams, such as Art Fletcher.
Most common positions on this list: P (104), OF (61), C (24), 2B (23).

How many can you name?

Name players who played for both the Phillies and the Giants. The surname is enough. 0 / 263

All 263 players, most games for the two first

Seasons and regular-season games with each franchise (1876–2025). A gap of a season or more starts a new spell.
Player	Pos	Phillies	Giants
Garry Maddox	OF	1975–1986 (1328 g)	1972–1975 (421 g)
Art Fletcher	SS	1920, 1922 (212 g)	1909–1920 (1325 g)
Pat Burrell	OF	2000–2008 (1306 g)	2010–2011 (188 g)
George Burns	OF	1925 (88 g)	1911–1921 (1362 g)
Kid Gleason	2B	1888–1891, 1903–1908 (767 g)	1896–1900 (673 g)
Dick Bartell	SS	1931–1934 (587 g)	1935–1938, 1941–1943, 1946 (835 g)
Mickey Doolin	SS	1905–1913 (1303 g)	1916 (18 g)
Red Dooin	C	1902–1914 (1220 g)	1915–1916 (61 g)
Roger Connor	1B	1892 (155 g)	1883–1889, 1891, 1893–1894 (1120 g)
Irish Meusel	OF	1918–1921 (482 g)	1921–1926 (765 g)
Dave Bancroft	SS	1915–1920 (681 g)	1920–1923, 1930 (534 g)
Pedro Feliz	3B	2008–2009 (291 g)	2000–2007 (874 g)
Gary Matthews	OF	1981–1983 (395 g)	1972–1976 (594 g)
Al Dark	SS	1960 (55 g)	1950–1956 (933 g)
Gus Mancuso	C	1945 (70 g)	1933–1938, 1942–1944 (882 g)
Hunter Pence	OF	2011–2012 (155 g)	2012–2018, 2020 (789 g)
Russ Wrightstone	3B	1920–1928 (900 g)	1928 (30 g)
Freddy Leach	OF	1923–1928 (539 g)	1929–1931 (368 g)
Willie Montanez	1B	1970–1975, 1982 (651 g)	1975–1976 (195 g)
Jack Doyle	1B	1904 (65 g)	1892–1895, 1898–1900, 1902 (746 g)
George Browne	OF	1901–1902, 1912 (84 g)	1902–1907 (719 g)
Aaron Rowand	OF	2006–2007 (270 g)	2008–2011 (509 g)
Charlie Hayes	3B	1989–1991, 1995 (519 g)	1988–1989, 1998–1999 (216 g)
Eddie Grant	3B	1907–1910 (527 g)	1913–1915 (203 g)
Manny Trillo	2B	1979–1982 (502 g)	1984–1985 (223 g)
Hans Lobert	3B	1911–1914 (497 g)	1915–1917 (205 g)
Jose Pagan	SS	1973 (46 g)	1959–1965 (655 g)
Johnny Vergez	3B	1935–1936 (163 g)	1931–1934 (501 g)
Beals Becker	OF	1913–1915 (338 g)	1910–1912 (298 g)
David Bell	3B	2003–2006 (470 g)	2002 (154 g)
Lou Chiozza	2B	1934–1936 (402 g)	1937–1939 (214 g)
Dave Rader	C	1979 (31 g)	1971–1976 (583 g)
Walter Holke	1B	1923–1925 (334 g)	1914, 1916–1918 (277 g)
Jack Boyle	C	1893–1898 (487 g)	1892 (120 g)
Harvey Kuenn	OF	1966 (86 g)	1961–1965 (515 g)
Milt Stock	3B	1915–1918 (474 g)	1913–1914 (122 g)
Fresco Thompson	2B	1927–1930 (575 g)	1926, 1934 (3 g)
Butch Henline	C	1921–1926 (576 g)	1921 (1 g)
Lefty O'Doul	OF	1929–1930 (294 g)	1928, 1933–1934 (275 g)
Bill White	1B	1966–1968 (396 g)	1956, 1958 (164 g)
Ethan Allen	OF	1934–1936 (331 g)	1930–1932 (224 g)
Ollie Brown	OF	1974–1977 (272 g)	1965–1968 (281 g)
Sam Mertes	OF	1896 (37 g)	1903–1906 (508 g)
Darin Ruf	1B	2012–2016 (286 g)	2020–2023 (256 g)
Nate Schierholtz	OF	2012 (37 g)	2007–2012 (503 g)
Stan Javier	OF	1992 (74 g)	1996–1999 (460 g)
Morrie Arnovich	OF	1936–1940 (442 g)	1941, 1946 (86 g)
Jerry Martin	OF	1974–1978 (444 g)	1981 (72 g)
Kiddo Davis	OF	1932, 1934 (237 g)	1933, 1935–1937 (277 g)
Steve Carlton	P	1972–1986 (501 g)	1986 (6 g)
Benito Santiago	C	1996 (136 g)	2001–2003 (367 g)
Eddie Burke	OF	1890 (100 g)	1892–1895 (401 g)
Josh Devore	OF	1913–1914 (56 g)	1908–1913 (436 g)
Billy Lauder	3B	1898–1899 (248 g)	1902–1903 (235 g)
Chick Fullis	OF	1933–1934 (179 g)	1928–1932 (295 g)
Ivan de Jesus	SS	1982–1984 (463 g)	1987 (9 g)
George Harper	OF	1924–1926 (297 g)	1927–1928 (164 g)
Chuck Hiller	2B	1967 (31 g)	1961–1965 (429 g)
Marlon Byrd	OF	2002–2005, 2014 (410 g)	2015 (39 g)
Mike Grady	C	1894–1897 (183 g)	1898–1900 (263 g)
Chris James	OF	1986–1989 (326 g)	1992 (111 g)
Derrel Thomas	2B	1985 (63 g)	1975–1977 (373 g)
Felix Rodriguez	P	2004 (23 g)	1999–2004 (395 g)
Bert Niehoff	2B	1915–1917 (410 g)	1918 (7 g)
John Barry	OF	1901–1904 (379 g)	1908 (38 g)
Curt Walker	OF	1921–1924 (333 g)	1920–1921 (72 g)
Ramon Martinez	SS	2005 (33 g)	1998–2002 (368 g)
Phil Weintraub	1B	1938 (100 g)	1933–1935, 1937, 1944–1945 (295 g)
Andrew McCutchen	OF	2019–2021 (260 g)	2018 (130 g)
Bennie Warren	C	1939–1942 (335 g)	1946–1947 (42 g)
Harry McCormick	OF	1908 (11 g)	1904, 1908–1909, 1912–1913 (353 g)
Jeff Brantley	P	1999–2000 (65 g)	1988–1993 (299 g)
Ruben Gomez	P	1959–1960, 1967 (53 g)	1953–1958 (306 g)
Jack Lohrke	3B	1952–1953 (37 g)	1947–1951 (318 g)
Kevin Frandsen	2B	2012–2013 (174 g)	2006–2009, 2015 (181 g)
Jackie Brandt	OF	1966–1967 (98 g)	1956, 1958–1959 (253 g)
Tim Worrell	P	2004–2005 (96 g)	2001–2003, 2006 (252 g)
Joe Morgan	2B	1983 (123 g)	1981–1982 (224 g)
Tim Keefe	P	1891–1893 (72 g)	1885–1889, 1891 (273 g)
Stu Miller	P	1956 (29 g)	1957–1962 (310 g)
Mickey Livingston	C	1941–1943 (269 g)	1947–1949 (69 g)
Mike Benjamin	SS	1996 (35 g)	1989–1995 (299 g)
Aaron Altherr	OF	2014–2019 (332 g)	2019 (1 g)
Johnny Rawlings	2B	1920–1921 (158 g)	1921–1922 (174 g)
Casey Stengel	OF	1920–1921 (153 g)	1921–1923 (177 g)
Frank Linzy	P	1974 (22 g)	1963, 1965–1970 (308 g)
Blondy Ryan	SS	1935 (39 g)	1933–1934, 1937–1938 (289 g)
Steve Bedrosian	P	1986–1989 (218 g)	1989–1990 (108 g)
Scott Eyre	P	2008–2009 (61 g)	2002–2005 (264 g)
Ricky Ledee	OF	2002–2004 (290 g)	2004 (31 g)
Emmanuel Burriss	2B	2016 (39 g)	2008–2012 (281 g)
Andrew Knapp	C	2017–2021 (309 g)	2022, 2024 (6 g)
Jack Sanford	P	1956–1958 (74 g)	1959–1965 (238 g)
Jim Hearn	P	1957–1959 (81 g)	1950–1956 (226 g)
Tom Herr	2B	1989–1990 (270 g)	1991 (32 g)
Al Holland	P	1983–1985 (139 g)	1979–1982 (162 g)
Wayne Gomes	P	1997–2001 (288 g)	2001 (13 g)
Aaron Fultz	P	2005–2006 (128 g)	2000–2002 (168 g)
Clarence Mitchell	P	1923–1928 (236 g)	1930–1932 (59 g)
Steve Scarsone	2B	1992 (7 g)	1993–1996 (281 g)
Marv Blaylock	1B	1955–1957 (286 g)	1950 (1 g)
Red Ames	P	1919 (3 g)	1903–1913 (282 g)
Mickey Haslin	SS	1933–1936 (224 g)	1937–1938 (58 g)
Jack Scott	P	1927 (83 g)	1922–1923, 1925–1926, 1928–1929 (195 g)
Jose Mesa	P	2001–2003, 2007 (246 g)	1998 (32 g)
Goldie Rapp	3B	1921–1923 (218 g)	1921 (58 g)
George Watkins	OF	1935–1936 (169 g)	1934 (105 g)
Andy Hansen	P	1951–1953 (97 g)	1944–1945, 1947–1950 (174 g)
Mark Davis	P	1980–1981, 1993 (36 g)	1983–1987 (231 g)
Michael Tucker	OF	2005 (22 g)	2004–2005 (244 g)
Mark Lewis	2B	1998 (142 g)	1997 (118 g)
Jimmy Ring	P	1921–1925, 1928 (220 g)	1926 (39 g)
Lee King	OF	1921–1922 (83 g)	1919–1922 (175 g)
Connie Ryan	2B	1952–1953 (244 g)	1942 (11 g)
Jack Dunn	3B	1900–1901 (12 g)	1902–1904 (243 g)
Buddy Blattner	2B	1949 (64 g)	1946–1948 (189 g)
Kim Batiste	3B	1991–1994 (197 g)	1996 (54 g)
Jack Bentley	P	1926 (75 g)	1923–1927 (173 g)
Michael Jackson	P	1986–1987 (64 g)	1992–1994 (184 g)
Terry Mulholland	P	1989–1993, 1996 (170 g)	1986, 1988–1989, 1995, 1997 (74 g)
Dave Philley	OF	1958–1960 (204 g)	1960 (39 g)
Glen Stewart	SS	1943–1944 (228 g)	1940 (15 g)
Tully Sparks	P	1897, 1903–1910 (224 g)	1902 (16 g)
Tyler Walker	P	2009 (32 g)	2004–2008 (205 g)
Ron Roenicke	OF	1986–1987 (165 g)	1985 (65 g)
Dick Buckley	C	1894–1895 (81 g)	1890–1891 (145 g)
William Brown	C	1891 (115 g)	1887–1889 (109 g)
Mike Krukow	P	1982 (33 g)	1983–1989 (188 g)
Gene Paulette	1B	1919–1920 (210 g)	1911 (10 g)
Valmy Thomas	C	1959 (66 g)	1957–1958 (151 g)
Ken Trinkle	P	1949 (42 g)	1943, 1946–1948 (174 g)
Bobby Estalella	C	1996–1999 (76 g)	2000–2001 (135 g)
Jack Taylor	P	1892–1897 (208 g)	1891 (1 g)
Jerry Spradlin	P	1997–1998 (145 g)	1999 (59 g)
Jack Taschner	P	2009 (24 g)	2005–2008 (178 g)
Kid Carsey	P	1892–1897 (195 g)	1899 (5 g)
Dick Groat	SS	1966–1967 (165 g)	1967 (34 g)
Jerry Johnson	P	1968–1969 (49 g)	1970–1972 (148 g)
John Bowker	1B	2011 (12 g)	2008–2010 (183 g)
Don Robinson	P	1992 (10 g)	1987–1991 (183 g)
Randy Lerch	P	1975–1980, 1986 (149 g)	1983–1984 (44 g)
Al Smith	P	1938–1939 (42 g)	1934–1937 (146 g)
Bill Lohrman	P	1934 (4 g)	1937–1943 (182 g)
George Smith	P	1919–1922 (155 g)	1916–1919 (31 g)
Al Demaree	P	1915–1916 (71 g)	1912–1914, 1917–1918 (112 g)
Hack Wilson	OF	1934 (7 g)	1923–1925 (172 g)
Dick Coffman	P	1945 (14 g)	1936–1939 (163 g)
Pop Schriver	C	1888–1890 (152 g)	1895 (24 g)
Jim Poole	P	1999 (51 g)	1996–1998 (124 g)
Kevin Correia	P	2015 (5 g)	2003–2008 (170 g)
Bill Hubbell	P	1920–1925 (156 g)	1919–1920 (16 g)
J. R. Phillips	1B	1996 (35 g)	1993–1996 (133 g)
Steve Ridzik	P	1950, 1952–1955, 1966 (107 g)	1956–1957 (60 g)
Joe Oeschger	P	1914–1919, 1924 (149 g)	1919, 1924 (15 g)
Jose Alvarez	P	2019–2020 (75 g)	2021–2022 (88 g)
Felipe Crespo	OF	2001 (33 g)	2000–2001 (129 g)
Mike Fontenot	2B	2012 (47 g)	2010–2011 (113 g)
Ed Daily	P	1885–1887 (155 g)	1890 (4 g)
Ed Sicking	2B	1919 (61 g)	1918–1920 (98 g)
Al Glossop	2B	1942 (121 g)	1939–1940 (37 g)
Homer Peel	OF	1929 (53 g)	1933–1934 (105 g)
Kenny Lofton	OF	2005 (110 g)	2002 (46 g)
Mark Leiter	P	1997–1998 (100 g)	1995–1996 (53 g)
Bert Haas	1B	1948–1949 (97 g)	1949 (54 g)
Harry Lyons	OF	1887 (1 g)	1889, 1892–1893 (148 g)
Vince DiMaggio	OF	1945–1946 (133 g)	1946 (15 g)
Erik Kratz	C	2011–2013, 2015 (132 g)	2019 (15 g)
Jose Cardenal	OF	1978–1979 (116 g)	1963–1964 (29 g)
Jimmy Smith	2B	1921–1922 (105 g)	1917 (37 g)
Jeff Francoeur	OF	2015 (119 g)	2013 (22 g)
Red Donahue	P	1898–1901 (136 g)	1893 (2 g)
Jerry Denny	3B	1891 (19 g)	1890–1891 (118 g)
Cody Ransom	SS	2010 (22 g)	2001–2004 (114 g)
Red Causey	P	1920–1921 (52 g)	1918–1919, 1921–1922 (84 g)
Kirby Higbe	P	1939–1940 (75 g)	1949–1950 (55 g)
Wayland Dean	P	1926–1927 (66 g)	1924–1925 (59 g)
Joe Bowman	P	1935–1936 (93 g)	1934 (31 g)
Al Oliver	OF	1984 (28 g)	1984 (91 g)
Chris Brock	P	2000–2001 (87 g)	1998–1999 (32 g)
Jesse Winters	P	1921–1923 (73 g)	1919–1920 (37 g)
Claude Cooper	OF	1916–1917 (80 g)	1913 (28 g)
Sam Coonrod	P	2021–2022 (54 g)	2019–2020 (51 g)
Jimmie Coker	C	1958, 1960–1962 (99 g)	1963 (4 g)
Yunior Marte	P	2023–2024 (63 g)	2022 (39 g)
Jack Sharrott	P	1893 (50 g)	1890–1892 (46 g)
Craig Robinson	SS	1972–1973 (51 g)	1975–1976 (44 g)
Wally Berger	OF	1940 (20 g)	1937–1938 (75 g)
Buck Jordan	1B	1938 (87 g)	1927, 1929 (7 g)
Steve Frey	P	1995–1996 (40 g)	1994–1995 (53 g)
Roberto Hernandez	P	2004 (63 g)	1997 (28 g)
Dennis Cook	P	1989–1990, 2001 (84 g)	1988–1989 (6 g)
Hub Pruett	P	1927–1928 (44 g)	1930 (45 g)
Jerome Williams	P	2014–2015 (42 g)	2003–2005 (47 g)
Renie Martin	P	1984 (9 g)	1982–1984 (79 g)
Jimmy Cooney	SS	1927 (76 g)	1919 (5 g)
Don Landrum	OF	1957 (2 g)	1966 (72 g)
Doug Baird	3B	1919 (66 g)	1920 (7 g)
Jack Kraus	P	1943, 1945 (54 g)	1946 (17 g)
Jim Hegan	C	1958–1959 (50 g)	1959 (21 g)
Cozy Dolan	OF	1912–1913 (67 g)	1922 (1 g)
Matt Moore	P	2021 (24 g)	2016–2017 (44 g)
Ed Vosberg	P	2000–2001 (49 g)	1990 (18 g)
Mark Portugal	P	1997–1998 (29 g)	1994–1995 (38 g)
Luke Williams	OF	2021 (58 g)	2022 (8 g)
Francisco Melendez	1B	1984, 1986 (30 g)	1987–1988 (35 g)
Dan Schatzeder	P	1986–1987 (51 g)	1982 (13 g)
Lew Wendell	C	1924–1926 (41 g)	1915–1916 (22 g)
Euel Moore	P	1934–1936 (55 g)	1935 (6 g)
Jack Berly	P	1932–1933 (34 g)	1931 (27 g)
Roger Mason	P	1993–1994 (40 g)	1985–1987 (21 g)
Johan Camargo	3B	2022 (52 g)	2023 (8 g)
John Monroe	2B	1921 (41 g)	1921 (19 g)
Dan Brouthers	1B	1896 (57 g)	1904 (2 g)
Doc Marshall	C	1904 (8 g)	1904, 1906 (49 g)
Jeff Juden	P	1994–1995 (19 g)	1996 (36 g)
Chase d'Arnaud	SS	2015 (11 g)	2018 (42 g)
Joe Roa	P	2002–2003 (20 g)	1997 (28 g)
Bob Hall	OF	1904 (46 g)	1905 (1 g)
Tony Kaufmann	P	1927 (8 g)	1929 (39 g)
Art Jahn	OF	1928 (36 g)	1928 (10 g)
Randy O'Neal	P	1989 (20 g)	1990 (26 g)
Chet Nichols	P	1930–1932 (41 g)	1928 (3 g)
John Morris	P	1966 (13 g)	1972–1974 (31 g)
Aramis Garcia	C	2024 (3 g)	2018–2019 (37 g)
Ed Hemingway	2B	1918 (33 g)	1917 (7 g)
Ledell Titcomb	P	1886 (5 g)	1887–1889 (35 g)
Brian Bocock	SS	2010 (6 g)	2008 (32 g)
Ernie Maun	P	1926 (14 g)	1924 (22 g)
Donovan Walton	2B	2025 (2 g)	2022, 2024 (33 g)
Ray Harrell	P	1939 (22 g)	1945 (12 g)
Dave LaPoint	P	1991 (2 g)	1985 (31 g)
Manny Salvo	P	1943 (1 g)	1939 (32 g)
Scott Service	P	1988 (5 g)	1995 (28 g)
Nick Vincent	P	2019 (14 g)	2019 (18 g)
Andrew Vasquez	P	2023 (30 g)	2022 (1 g)
Hank Ritter	P	1912 (3 g)	1914–1916 (27 g)
Tom Fleming	OF	1902, 1904 (8 g)	1899 (22 g)
Cal Stevenson	OF	2024–2025 (23 g)	2023 (6 g)
Jocko Fields	OF	1891 (8 g)	1892 (21 g)
Mauricio Llovera	P	2020–2021 (7 g)	2022–2023 (22 g)
Alejandro Sanchez	OF	1982–1983 (15 g)	1984 (13 g)
Billy Sorrell	3B	1965 (10 g)	1967 (18 g)
Bill Magee	P	1899, 1902 (17 g)	1901–1902 (8 g)
Mickey Devine	C	1918 (4 g)	1925 (21 g)
Al Maul	OF	1887, 1900 (21 g)	1901 (3 g)
Spencer Howard	P	2020–2021 (17 g)	2024 (7 g)
Les Powers	1B	1939 (19 g)	1938 (2 g)
Lou Trivino	P	2025 (10 g)	2025 (11 g)
Luis Ortiz	P	2023–2024 (15 g)	2022 (6 g)
Heath Hembree	P	2020 (11 g)	2013 (9 g)
Drew Smyly	P	2019 (12 g)	2020 (7 g)
Brian Powell	P	2004 (17 g)	2003 (1 g)
Harry Felix	P	1902 (16 g)	1901 (1 g)
Brad Brink	P	1992–1993 (10 g)	1994 (4 g)
Libe Washburn	OF	1903 (8 g)	1902 (6 g)
Kent Bottenfield	P	2000 (8 g)	1994 (1 g)
Hugh Poland	C	1947 (4 g)	1943 (4 g)
Pat Ragan	P	1923 (1 g)	1919 (7 g)
Jim Deshaies	P	1995 (2 g)	1993 (5 g)
Paul Erickson	P	1948 (4 g)	1948 (2 g)
Youngy Johnson	P	1897 (5 g)	1899 (1 g)
Jim Devlin	P	1887 (2 g)	1886 (1 g)
Rob Brantly	C	2019 (1 g)	2020 (1 g)

From the SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0), 1876–2025. A season counts when the player played at least one regular-season game for the franchise.Phillies seasons include the Philadelphia Quakers (1883–1889) and Philadelphia Blue Jays (1943–1944).Giants seasons include the New York Gothams (1883–1884) and New York Giants (1885–1957).

What next? Play today's MLB Grid

Fill a 3×3 board of team pairs like this one, with nine guesses and a rarity score. New board every day.

Play the MLB Grid MLB career path Phillies history Giants history

More “played for both” lists

Philadelphia Phillies and…

Cardinals 323 Cubs 322 Reds 285 Pirates 281 Braves 268 Dodgers 265 Guardians 202 Orioles 200 Red Sox 190 White Sox 183

San Francisco Giants and…

Cardinals 290 Braves 289 Cubs 288 Reds 266 Dodgers 254 Pirates 252 Yankees 185 Guardians 178 Athletics 170 Red Sox 170

All MLB team pairs

Questions

How many players have played for both the Philadelphia Phillies and the San Francisco Giants?

263 in the Lahman Baseball Database from 1883 to 2025, including Garry Maddox, Art Fletcher, Pat Burrell and George Burns. A player counts when he played at least one regular-season game for each franchise.

Who was the first player on this list to play for both?

Jim Devlin: San Francisco Giants first, then the Philadelphia Phillies from 1887.

Who has played for both recently?

Andrew Knapp, Yunior Marte, Aramis Garcia, Donovan Walton, Cal Stevenson and Spencer Howard and 2 more, with a season for one of the two in 2024 or 2025.

Does a player count if the team has moved or changed its name?

Yes. Seasons count for today's franchise, the way the Lahman database links every team-season to a franchise. Phillies seasons include the Philadelphia Quakers (1883–1889) and Philadelphia Blue Jays (1943–1944). Giants seasons include the New York Gothams (1883–1884) and New York Giants (1885–1957).

Careers from the SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0). Team logos are trademarks of their respective teams (logos via TheSportsDB). Independent and not affiliated with MLB or any team. Credits