Cleveland Guardians and New York Yankees players: who played for both

Who played for both the Guardians and Yankees?

275 players played for both the Cleveland Guardians and the New York Yankees between 1901 and 2025, including Graig Nettles, Joe Sewell, Joe Gordon and Steve O'Neill. 139 of them played for the Guardians first and 126 for the Yankees first; 10 played for both in the same season.

Did you know?

George Yeager is the earliest on this list to complete the pair: Guardians first, then the Yankees from 1902.
Carlos Carrasco is the most recent: Guardians first, then the Yankees from 2025.
Graig Nettles played the most games across the two: 465 for the Guardians and 1,535 for the Yankees.
57 of them had two or more separate spells with one of the teams, such as Joe Gordon.
Most common positions on this list: P (116), OF (68), C (25), SS (19).

How many can you name?

Name players who played for both the Guardians and the Yankees. The surname is enough. 0 / 275

All 275 players, most games for the two first

Seasons and regular-season games with each franchise (1876–2025). A gap of a season or more starts a new spell.
Player	Pos	Guardians	Yankees
Graig Nettles	3B	1970–1972 (465 g)	1973–1983 (1535 g)
Joe Sewell	SS	1920–1930 (1513 g)	1931–1933 (390 g)
Joe Gordon	2B	1947–1950 (566 g)	1938–1943, 1946 (1000 g)
Steve O'Neill	C	1911–1923 (1365 g)	1925 (35 g)
Kenny Lofton	OF	1992–1996, 1998–2001, 2007 (1276 g)	2004 (83 g)
Roger Peckinpaugh	SS	1910, 1912–1913 (86 g)	1913–1921 (1220 g)
Chris Chambliss	1B	1971–1974 (404 g)	1974–1979, 1988 (885 g)
Dave Winfield	OF	1995 (46 g)	1981–1988, 1990 (1172 g)
Ben Chapman	OF	1939–1940 (292 g)	1930–1936 (910 g)
Travis Hafner	DH	2003–2012 (1078 g)	2013 (82 g)
Gene Woodling	OF	1943, 1946, 1955–1957 (381 g)	1949–1954 (699 g)
Mel Hall	OF	1984–1988 (538 g)	1989–1992 (519 g)
Lou Piniella	OF	1968 (6 g)	1974–1984 (1037 g)
Roger Maris	OF	1957–1958 (167 g)	1960–1966 (850 g)
Jason Giambi	1B	2013–2014 (97 g)	2002–2008 (897 g)
Rocky Colavito	OF	1955–1959, 1965–1967 (913 g)	1968 (39 g)
Snuffy Stirnweiss	2B	1951–1952 (51 g)	1943–1950 (884 g)
Aaron Ward	2B	1928 (6 g)	1917–1926 (911 g)
Oscar Gamble	OF	1973–1975 (369 g)	1976, 1979–1984 (540 g)
Nick Swisher	OF	2013–2015 (272 g)	2009–2012 (598 g)
Woodie Held	SS	1958–1964 (855 g)	1954, 1957 (5 g)
Toby Harrah	3B	1979–1983 (712 g)	1984 (88 g)
Lyn Lary	SS	1937–1939 (300 g)	1929–1934 (498 g)
Alvaro Espinoza	SS	1993–1996 (344 g)	1988–1991 (447 g)
George Burns	1B	1920–1921, 1924–1928 (758 g)	1928–1929 (13 g)
Ray Mack	2B	1938–1944, 1946 (769 g)	1947 (1 g)
Elmer Smith	OF	1914–1917, 1919–1921 (674 g)	1922–1923 (91 g)
Roy Weatherly	OF	1936–1942 (680 g)	1943, 1946 (79 g)
Ron Hassey	C	1978–1984 (569 g)	1985–1986 (156 g)
David Justice	OF	1997–2000 (486 g)	2000–2001 (189 g)
Melky Cabrera	OF	2018 (78 g)	2005–2009 (569 g)
Johnny Damon	OF	2012 (64 g)	2006–2009 (576 g)
Bill Knickerbocker	SS	1933–1936 (513 g)	1938–1940 (97 g)
Billy Martin	2B	1959 (73 g)	1950–1953, 1955–1957 (528 g)
Rick Cerone	C	1975–1976 (14 g)	1980–1984, 1987, 1990 (587 g)
Fred Stanley	SS	1971–1972 (66 g)	1973–1980 (521 g)
John Ellis	1B	1973–1975 (347 g)	1969–1972 (235 g)
Myril Hoag	OF	1944–1945 (107 g)	1931–1932, 1934–1938 (472 g)
Rollie Hemsley	C	1938–1941 (390 g)	1942–1944 (174 g)
Ray Caldwell	P	1919–1921 (87 g)	1910–1918 (475 g)
Charlie Spikes	OF	1973–1977 (539 g)	1972 (14 g)
CC Sabathia	P	2001–2008 (238 g)	2009–2019 (307 g)
Duke Sims	C	1964–1970 (536 g)	1973–1974 (9 g)
Oscar Grimes	3B	1938–1942 (262 g)	1943–1946 (281 g)
Dick Howser	SS	1963–1966 (385 g)	1967–1968 (148 g)
George Uhle	P	1919–1928, 1936 (502 g)	1933–1934 (22 g)
Les Nunamaker	C	1919–1922 (133 g)	1914–1917 (369 g)
Eric Plunk	P	1992–1998 (374 g)	1989–1991 (117 g)
Bob Wickman	P	2000–2002, 2004–2006 (255 g)	1992–1996 (223 g)
Allie Reynolds	P	1942–1946 (161 g)	1947–1954 (314 g)
Buddy Rosar	C	1943–1944 (214 g)	1939–1942 (252 g)
Jerry Kenney	3B	1973 (5 g)	1967, 1969–1972 (460 g)
Neal Ball	SS	1909–1912 (308 g)	1907–1909 (157 g)
Eddie Robinson	1B	1942, 1946–1948, 1957 (264 g)	1954–1956 (199 g)
Braggo Roth	OF	1915–1918 (415 g)	1921 (43 g)
Mike Fischlin	SS	1981–1985 (387 g)	1986 (71 g)
Enrique Wilson	2B	1997–2000 (190 g)	2001–2004 (264 g)
Harry Simpson	OF	1951–1953, 1955 (353 g)	1957–1958 (99 g)
Eddie Leon	2B	1968–1972 (442 g)	1975 (1 g)
Gio Urshela	3B	2015, 2017 (148 g)	2019–2021 (291 g)
Joel Skinner	C	1989–1991 (227 g)	1986–1988 (206 g)
Dion James	OF	1989–1990 (158 g)	1992–1993, 1995–1996 (273 g)
Chick Fewster	2B	1924–1925 (194 g)	1917–1922 (232 g)
Charlie Hemphill	OF	1902 (25 g)	1908–1911 (389 g)
Shane Spencer	OF	2003 (64 g)	1998–2002 (345 g)
Pedro Gonzalez	2B	1965–1967 (306 g)	1963–1965 (101 g)
Amed Rosario	SS	2021–2023 (388 g)	2025 (16 g)
Mark Whiten	OF	1991–1992, 1998–2000 (320 g)	1997 (69 g)
Matt Lawton	OF	2002–2004 (363 g)	2005 (21 g)
Stan Coveleski	P	1916–1924 (361 g)	1928 (12 g)
Sam McDowell	P	1961–1971 (340 g)	1973–1974 (29 g)
Chad Curtis	OF	1997 (22 g)	1997–1999 (340 g)
Ben Paschal	OF	1915 (9 g)	1924–1929 (347 g)
Fritz Peterson	P	1974–1976 (63 g)	1966–1974 (288 g)
Edwin Encarnacion	DH	2017–2018 (294 g)	2019 (44 g)
Paul Assenmacher	P	1995–1999 (309 g)	1993 (26 g)
Roy Cullenbine	OF	1943–1945 (300 g)	1942 (21 g)
Rusty Torres	OF	1973–1974 (231 g)	1971–1972 (89 g)
Steve Hamilton	P	1961 (2 g)	1963–1970 (313 g)
Jim Jackson	OF	1905–1906 (215 g)	1901 (99 g)
Shelley Duncan	OF	2010–2012 (242 g)	2007–2009 (68 g)
Aaron Boone	3B	2005–2006 (247 g)	2003 (54 g)
Richie Sexson	1B	1997–2000 (279 g)	2008 (22 g)
Dick Tidrow	P	1972–1974 (85 g)	1974–1979 (211 g)
Boone Logan	P	2017 (38 g)	2010–2013 (256 g)
Bobby Bonds	OF	1979 (146 g)	1975 (145 g)
Otis Nixon	OF	1984–1987 (277 g)	1983 (13 g)
Cliff Johnson	DH	1979–1980 (126 g)	1977–1979 (160 g)
Zach McAllister	P	2011–2018 (277 g)	2023 (7 g)
Joba Chamberlain	P	2016 (20 g)	2007–2013 (260 g)
Wes Ferrell	P	1927–1933 (267 g)	1938–1939 (8 g)
Carlos Carrasco	P	2009–2011, 2013–2020, 2024 (263 g)	2025 (8 g)
Pedro Ramos	P	1962–1964 (137 g)	1964–1966 (130 g)
Luis Tiant	P	1964–1969 (211 g)	1979–1980 (55 g)
Sad Sam Jones	P	1914–1915 (49 g)	1922–1926 (210 g)
Greg Allen	OF	2017–2020 (220 g)	2021, 2023 (37 g)
Ben Francisco	OF	2007–2009 (235 g)	2013 (21 g)
Steve Karsay	P	1998–2001 (164 g)	2002, 2004–2005 (91 g)
Johnny Allen	P	1936–1940 (157 g)	1932–1935 (94 g)
Glenallen Hill	OF	1991–1993 (205 g)	2000 (40 g)
Tommy John	P	1963–1964 (31 g)	1979–1982, 1986–1989 (214 g)
Jake Bauers	1B	2019, 2021 (160 g)	2023 (84 g)
Ralph Terry	P	1965 (30 g)	1956–1957, 1959–1964 (210 g)
Jayson Nix	3B	2010 (78 g)	2012–2013 (161 g)
Roxy Walters	C	1924–1925 (37 g)	1915–1918 (193 g)
Deacon McGuire	C	1908, 1910 (2 g)	1904–1907 (227 g)
Walt Williams	OF	1973 (104 g)	1974–1975 (125 g)
Tony Fernandez	SS	1997 (120 g)	1995 (108 g)
Corey Kluber	P	2011–2019 (210 g)	2021 (16 g)
Andrew Miller	P	2016–2018 (120 g)	2015–2016 (104 g)
Jake Westbrook	P	2001–2008, 2010 (218 g)	2000 (3 g)
Monte Pearson	P	1932–1935 (96 g)	1936–1940 (121 g)
Billy Hunter	SS	1958 (76 g)	1955–1956 (137 g)
Bob Seeds	OF	1930–1932, 1934 (196 g)	1936 (13 g)
Ricky Ledee	OF	2000 (17 g)	1998–2000 (192 g)
Steve Farr	P	1984, 1994 (50 g)	1991–1993 (159 g)
Oral Hildebrand	P	1931–1936 (171 g)	1939–1940 (34 g)
David Dellucci	OF	2007–2009 (183 g)	2003 (21 g)
Allie Clark	OF	1948–1951 (178 g)	1947 (24 g)
Rick Dempsey	C	1987 (60 g)	1973–1976 (141 g)
Bartolo Colon	P	1997–2002 (162 g)	2011 (29 g)
Larry Milbourne	2B	1982 (82 g)	1981–1983 (106 g)
Dave LaRoche	P	1975–1977 (135 g)	1981–1983 (52 g)
Don Hood	P	1975–1979 (160 g)	1979 (27 g)
Hank Majeski	3B	1952–1955 (179 g)	1946 (8 g)
Ray Barker	1B	1965 (11 g)	1965–1967 (176 g)
Jesse Orosco	P	1989–1991 (171 g)	2003 (15 g)
Josh Donaldson	3B	2018 (16 g)	2022–2023 (166 g)
Tim Hendryx	OF	1911–1912 (27 g)	1915–1917 (153 g)
Austin Kearns	OF	2010–2011 (141 g)	2010 (36 g)
Joe Harris	1B	1917, 1919 (174 g)	1914 (2 g)
Stan Williams	P	1965, 1967–1969 (124 g)	1963–1964 (51 g)
Earl Moore	P	1901–1907 (161 g)	1907 (12 g)
Tom Buskey	P	1974–1977 (161 g)	1973–1974 (12 g)
Alex Johnson	OF	1972 (108 g)	1974–1975 (62 g)
Harry Niles	OF	1910 (72 g)	1908 (95 g)
Cecil Fielder	1B	1998 (14 g)	1996–1997 (151 g)
Ron Kittle	OF	1988 (75 g)	1986–1987 (89 g)
George Frazier	P	1984 (22 g)	1981–1983 (140 g)
Pat Dobson	P	1976–1977 (68 g)	1973–1975 (94 g)
Jason Grimsley	P	1993–1995 (39 g)	1999–2000 (118 g)
Ken Phelps	DH	1990 (24 g)	1988–1989 (131 g)
Rafael Santana	SS	1990 (7 g)	1988 (148 g)
Frank Delahanty	OF	1907 (16 g)	1905–1906, 1908 (138 g)
Clyde Engle	1B	1916 (11 g)	1909–1910 (141 g)
Neal Heaton	P	1982–1986 (133 g)	1993 (18 g)
Bob Grim	P	1960 (3 g)	1954–1958 (146 g)
Karim Garcia	OF	2001–2003 (95 g)	2002–2003 (54 g)
Wilbur Good	OF	1908–1909 (140 g)	1905 (5 g)
Gaylord Perry	P	1972–1975 (134 g)	1980 (10 g)
Mike Kekich	P	1973 (19 g)	1969–1973 (125 g)
Jaret Wright	P	1997–2002 (98 g)	2005–2006 (44 g)
Nick Goody	P	2017–2019 (107 g)	2015–2016 (34 g)
Scott Kamieniecki	P	2000 (26 g)	1991–1996 (113 g)
Jimmie Hall	OF	1968–1969 (57 g)	1969 (80 g)
Mark Reynolds	3B	2013 (99 g)	2013 (36 g)
Ron Villone	P	1998 (25 g)	2006–2007 (107 g)
Dell Alston	OF	1979–1980 (106 g)	1977–1978 (25 g)
Bud Daley	P	1955–1957 (50 g)	1961–1964 (80 g)
Tom Brookens	3B	1990 (64 g)	1989 (66 g)
Jose Veras	P	2009 (22 g)	2006–2009 (106 g)
Tyler Clippard	P	2019 (53 g)	2007, 2016–2017 (75 g)
Chris Dickerson	OF	2014 (41 g)	2011–2012 (85 g)
Jeff Manto	3B	1990–1991, 1997–1999 (120 g)	1999 (6 g)
Enyel De Los Santos	P	2022–2023 (120 g)	2024 (5 g)
Bob Hale	1B	1960–1961 (112 g)	1961 (11 g)
Buster Mills	OF	1942, 1946 (89 g)	1940 (34 g)
Tim Stoddard	P	1989 (14 g)	1986–1988 (109 g)
Johnny Broaca	P	1939 (22 g)	1934–1937 (99 g)
Jose Vizcaino	SS	1996 (48 g)	2000 (73 g)
Phil Niekro	P	1986–1987 (56 g)	1984–1985 (65 g)
Mike Aldrete	OF	1991 (85 g)	1996 (32 g)
Bill Zuber	P	1936, 1938–1940 (50 g)	1943–1946 (66 g)
Dwight Gooden	P	1998–1999 (49 g)	1996–1997, 2000 (67 g)
Otto Velez	OF	1983 (10 g)	1973–1976 (105 g)
Steve Kline	P	1974 (16 g)	1970–1974 (97 g)
Tyler Olson	P	2017–2019 (112 g)	2016 (1 g)
Bob Kuzava	P	1946–1947 (6 g)	1951–1954 (105 g)
Jack Lelivelt	OF	1913–1914 (57 g)	1912–1913 (54 g)
Paul Zuvella	SS	1988–1989 (75 g)	1986–1987 (35 g)
Bill Sudakis	3B	1975 (20 g)	1974 (89 g)
Doc Edwards	C	1962–1963 (63 g)	1965 (45 g)
Fred Beene	P	1974–1975 (53 g)	1972–1974 (55 g)
Red Embree	P	1941–1942, 1944–1947 (87 g)	1948 (20 g)
Cecilio Guante	P	1990 (26 g)	1987–1988 (79 g)
Kerry Wood	P	2009–2010 (81 g)	2010 (24 g)
Harvey Hendrick	1B	1925 (25 g)	1923–1924 (78 g)
David Huff	P	2009–2013 (58 g)	2013–2014 (41 g)
Jack Thoney	OF	1902–1903 (60 g)	1902, 1904 (39 g)
Lou Clinton	OF	1965 (12 g)	1966–1967 (86 g)
Luis Aguayo	SS	1989 (47 g)	1988 (50 g)
Joe Borowski	P	2007–2008 (87 g)	1997–1998 (9 g)
Ed Klepfer	P	1915–1917, 1919 (85 g)	1911, 1913 (10 g)
Mark Wohlers	P	2002 (64 g)	2001 (31 g)
Jumbo Brown	P	1927–1928 (13 g)	1932–1933, 1935–1936 (80 g)
Al Gettel	P	1947–1948 (39 g)	1945–1946 (53 g)
Aaron Laffey	P	2007–2010 (79 g)	2011 (11 g)
Luis Vizcaino	P	2009 (11 g)	2007 (77 g)
Terry Mulholland	P	2002–2003 (61 g)	1994 (24 g)
Ed Whitson	P	1982 (40 g)	1985–1986 (44 g)
Estevan Florial	OF	2024 (36 g)	2020–2023 (48 g)
Nick Cullop	P	1913–1914 (24 g)	1916–1917 (58 g)
Larry Rosenthal	OF	1941 (45 g)	1944 (36 g)
Esmil Rogers	P	2012 (44 g)	2014–2015 (36 g)
Mark Salas	C	1989 (30 g)	1987 (50 g)
Eddie Phillips	C	1935 (70 g)	1932 (9 g)
Tom Ferrick	P	1942, 1946 (40 g)	1950–1951 (39 g)
Walter Clarkson	P	1907–1908 (19 g)	1904–1907 (59 g)
Rich Hill	P	2013 (63 g)	2014 (14 g)
Alan Embree	P	1992, 1995–1996 (51 g)	2005 (24 g)
Gus Fisher	C	1911 (71 g)	1912 (4 g)
Clay Rapada	P	2013 (4 g)	2012 (70 g)
Pete Appleton	P	1930–1932 (73 g)	1933 (1 g)
Jerry Moses	C	1972 (52 g)	1973 (21 g)
Shawn Hillegas	P	1991 (51 g)	1992 (21 g)
Neil Allen	P	1989 (3 g)	1985, 1987–1988 (66 g)
Jack McDowell	P	1996–1997 (38 g)	1995 (30 g)
Mike Armstrong	P	1987 (14 g)	1984–1986 (52 g)
Blake Parker	P	2021 (47 g)	2016 (16 g)
Ivy Andrews	P	1937 (20 g)	1931–1932, 1937–1938 (41 g)
Sherm Lollar	C	1946 (28 g)	1947–1948 (33 g)
Josh Phelps	DH	2004 (24 g)	2007 (36 g)
Don Schulze	P	1984–1986 (57 g)	1989 (2 g)
Marty McHale	P	1916 (5 g)	1913–1915 (54 g)
Stan Jefferson	OF	1990 (49 g)	1989 (10 g)
Brent Lillibridge	OF	2012 (43 g)	2013 (11 g)
A. J. Cole	P	2019 (25 g)	2018 (28 g)
Jay Bruce	OF	2017 (43 g)	2021 (10 g)
Ken Holloway	P	1929–1930 (37 g)	1930 (16 g)
Bill Wight	P	1953, 1955 (37 g)	1946–1947 (15 g)
Billy Traber	P	2003 (33 g)	2008 (19 g)
Eddie Bockman	3B	1947 (46 g)	1946 (4 g)
George Yeager	C	1901 (39 g)	1902 (11 g)
Chris Turner	C	1999 (12 g)	2000 (37 g)
Carl Pavano	P	2009 (21 g)	2005, 2007–2008 (26 g)
Al Cicotte	P	1959 (26 g)	1957 (20 g)
Joe Connor	C	1901 (37 g)	1905 (8 g)
Cecil Upshaw	P	1974 (7 g)	1974 (36 g)
Martin Autry	C	1926–1928 (41 g)	1924 (2 g)
Sal Fasano	C	2008 (15 g)	2006 (28 g)
Elmer Valo	OF	1959 (34 g)	1960 (8 g)
Charles Wensloff	P	1948 (1 g)	1943, 1947 (40 g)
Ryan Thompson	OF	1996 (8 g)	2000 (33 g)
Josh Outman	P	2014 (31 g)	2014 (9 g)
Stan Thomas	P	1976 (37 g)	1977 (3 g)
Derek Lowe	P	2012 (21 g)	2012 (17 g)
Anthony Swarzak	P	2015 (10 g)	2016 (26 g)
Bobby Tiefenauer	P	1960, 1965, 1967 (26 g)	1965 (10 g)
Nick Cullop	OF	1927 (32 g)	1926 (2 g)
Andrew Velazquez	SS	2019 (5 g)	2021 (28 g)
David Weathers	P	1997 (9 g)	1996–1997 (21 g)
Jim Brower	P	1999–2000 (26 g)	2007 (3 g)
Rob Gardner	P	1968 (5 g)	1970–1972 (23 g)
Torey Lovullo	2B	1998 (6 g)	1991 (22 g)
Brian Dorsett	C	1987 (5 g)	1989–1990 (22 g)
Jason Anderson	P	2004 (1 g)	2003, 2005 (25 g)
Sal Maglie	P	1955–1956 (12 g)	1957–1958 (13 g)
Bob Muncrief	P	1948 (21 g)	1951 (2 g)
Domingo Ramos	SS	1988 (22 g)	1978 (1 g)
Dan Miceli	P	2003 (13 g)	2003 (7 g)
Ted Sepkowski	2B	1942, 1946–1947 (17 g)	1947 (2 g)
Ben Gamel	OF	2021 (11 g)	2016 (6 g)
Brad Arnsberg	P	1992 (8 g)	1986–1987 (8 g)
Ernie Krueger	C	1913 (5 g)	1915 (10 g)
George Kontos	P	2018 (6 g)	2011, 2018 (8 g)
Jamie Quirk	C	1984 (1 g)	1989 (13 g)
Jeff Moronko	3B	1984 (7 g)	1987 (7 g)
Thomas Neal	OF	2012 (9 g)	2013 (4 g)
Bob Ojeda	P	1993 (9 g)	1994 (2 g)
Jeff Juden	P	1997 (8 g)	1999 (2 g)
Harry Ables	P	1909 (5 g)	1911 (3 g)
Mike Donovan	3B	1904 (2 g)	1908 (5 g)
Matt Luke	OF	1998 (2 g)	1996 (1 g)
Ted Gray	P	1955 (2 g)	1955 (1 g)
Germany Schaefer	2B	1918 (1 g)	1916 (1 g)

From the SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0), 1876–2025. A season counts when the player played at least one regular-season game for the franchise.Guardians seasons include the Cleveland Blues (1901), Cleveland Bronchos (1902), Cleveland Naps (1903–1914) and Cleveland Indians (1915–2021).Yankees seasons include the Baltimore Orioles (1901–1902) and New York Highlanders (1903–1912).

What next? Play today's MLB Grid

Fill a 3×3 board of team pairs like this one, with nine guesses and a rarity score. New board every day.

Play the MLB Grid MLB career path Guardians history Yankees history

More “played for both” lists

Cleveland Guardians and…

White Sox 292 Orioles 274 Red Sox 272 Athletics 260 Twins 238 Cubs 223 Reds 223 Tigers 223 Dodgers 205 Pirates 203

New York Yankees and…

Athletics 291 Orioles 279 Red Sox 255 White Sox 244 Dodgers 233 Reds 227 Braves 225 Twins 223 Pirates 223 Cubs 210

All MLB team pairs

Questions

How many players have played for both the Cleveland Guardians and the New York Yankees?

275 in the Lahman Baseball Database from 1901 to 2025, including Graig Nettles, Joe Sewell, Joe Gordon and Steve O'Neill. A player counts when he played at least one regular-season game for each franchise.

Who was the first player on this list to play for both?

George Yeager: Cleveland Guardians first, then the New York Yankees from 1902.

Who has played for both recently?

Amed Rosario, Carlos Carrasco, Enyel De Los Santos and Estevan Florial, with a season for one of the two in 2024 or 2025.

Does a player count if the team has moved or changed its name?

Yes. Seasons count for today's franchise, the way the Lahman database links every team-season to a franchise. Guardians seasons include the Cleveland Blues (1901), Cleveland Bronchos (1902), Cleveland Naps (1903–1914) and Cleveland Indians (1915–2021). Yankees seasons include the Baltimore Orioles (1901–1902) and New York Highlanders (1903–1912).

Careers from the SABR Lahman Baseball Database (CC BY-SA 3.0). Team logos are trademarks of their respective teams (logos via TheSportsDB). Independent and not affiliated with MLB or any team. Credits